Clinical trialLymphoma

Adapted Treatment Guided by Interim PET-CT Scan in Advanced Hodgkin’s Lymphoma

N Engl J Med · 20161214 patients registered; 1119 patients with interim PET-CT per protocol, of whom 937 (83.7%) had a negative result
Johnson P, Federico M, Kirkwood A, Fosså A, Berkahn L, Carella A, et al. N Engl J Med. 2016. 374:2419-2429
Study type
Clinical trial
Study name
RATHL
Design
Randomised non-inferiority trial with response-adapted treatment based on interim PET-CT (after 2 cycles of ABVD)
Sample size
1214 patients registered; 1119 patients with interim PET-CT per protocol, of whom 937 (83.7%) had a negative result
Source
N Engl J Med · 2016
Trial registration
NCT00678327

In plain words

In this study, patients with advanced Hodgkin lymphoma had a PET-CT scan after two cycles of first chemotherapy (ABVD) to measure their early response. In most patients (about 84%) the scan was negative, and leaving the drug bleomycin out of the rest of treatment kept the results almost the same and caused fewer lung side effects. Patients with a positive scan were moved to a stronger regimen (BEACOPP). Decisions about treatment should always be made with your treating doctor.

Key results

937 of 1119 patients (83.7%)
Negative interim PET-CT
Patients who had interim PET-CT per protocol
85.7% vs 84.4%
3-year progression-free survival (ABVD vs AVD)
95% CI 82.1–88.6 vs 80.7–87.5; median follow-up 41 months
97.2% vs 97.6%
3-year overall survival (ABVD vs AVD)
95% CI 95.1–98.4 vs 95.6–98.7
1.6 percentage points
Absolute difference in 3-year progression-free survival (ABVD minus AVD)
95% CI −3.2 to 5.3; slightly short of the specified non-inferiority margin
172 patients; 74.4% with a negative third PET-CT
Interim PET-positive patients who received BEACOPP
3-year progression-free survival 67.5% and overall survival 87.8%
3-year progression-free survival 82.6%; overall survival 95.8%
All patients
62 patients died during the trial (24 from Hodgkin lymphoma)

Dose and schedule cards

PET-guided ABVD (RATHL approach) and ABVD in limited-stage disease

Advanced classic Hodgkin lymphoma (interim PET-adapted approach); in limited stage: low-risk group, 2 cycles of ABVD followed by 20 Gy radiotherapy; in the less intensive approach for the high-risk group or patients over 60 years, 4 cycles of A(B)VD and 30 Gy radiotherapyCycle length: Every 28 daysOn the page “Lymphoma” · Treatment regimens and dosing: Hodgkin lymphoma

Advanced classic Hodgkin lymphoma (interim PET-adapted approach); in limited stage: low-risk group, 2 cycles of ABVD followed by 20 Gy radiotherapy; in the less intensive approach for the high-risk group or patients over 60 years, 4 cycles of A(B)VD and 30 Gy radiotherapy

DrugDoseRouteSchedule
Doxorubicin25 mg/m²IVDays 1 and 15
Bleomycin10 units/m²IVDays 1 and 15
Vinblastine6 mg/m²IVDays 1 and 15
Dacarbazine375 mg/m²IVDays 1 and 15
Cycle length
Every 28 days
Duration
Advanced disease: 2 cycles of ABVD, then interim PET-CT; PET-negative: 4 cycles of AVD (bleomycin omitted); PET-positive: intensification to escalated BEACOPP

Doses from the ClinicalTrials.gov registration of the ECHELON-1 trial (ABVD arm); the adaptive approach from RATHL and the limited-stage schedule from the EHA guideline. In RATHL, omitting bleomycin after a negative PET reduced pulmonary toxicity without a significant loss of efficacy, and radiotherapy was not recommended for patients with a negative interim PET.

On the page “Lymphoma” · Treatment regimens and dosing: Hodgkin lymphoma

Escalated BEACOPP (eBEACOPP)

Unfavorable limited-stage Hodgkin lymphoma in patients aged 60 years or younger (2 cycles of eBEACOPP followed by 2 cycles of ABVD); treatment escalation after a positive interim PET on ABVDCycle length: Every 21 daysOn the page “Lymphoma” · Treatment regimens and dosing: Hodgkin lymphoma

Unfavorable limited-stage Hodgkin lymphoma in patients aged 60 years or younger (2 cycles of eBEACOPP followed by 2 cycles of ABVD); treatment escalation after a positive interim PET on ABVD

DrugDoseRouteSchedule
Etoposide200 mg/m²IVDays 1–3
Doxorubicin35 mg/m²IVDay 1
Cyclophosphamide1250 mg/m²IVDay 1
Bleomycin10 mg/m²IVDay 8
Vincristine1.4 mg/m²IVDay 8
Procarbazine100 mg/m²OralDays 1–7
Prednisone40 mg/m²OralDays 1–14
Cycle length
Every 21 days
Duration
Unfavorable limited stage: 2 cycles followed by 2 cycles of ABVD; 30 Gy radiotherapy only if PET is positive at the end of chemotherapy

Doses from the abstract of the HD21 trial (eBEACOPP arm); its role in limited-stage disease from the EHA guideline. The accelerated version (BEACOPP-14) is given with granulocyte growth factor support. eBEACOPP carries a risk of permanent infertility, prolonged fatigue and myelodysplasia or acute leukaemia.

On the page “Lymphoma” · Treatment regimens and dosing: Hodgkin lymphoma

ABVD

Classical Hodgkin lymphomaCycle length: Every 28 daysOn the page “ABVD in Hodgkin lymphoma and AVD after a negative PET”

Classical Hodgkin lymphoma

DrugDoseRouteSchedule
Doxorubicin25 mg/m²IVDays 1 and 15
Bleomycin10 units/m²IVDays 1 and 15
Vinblastine6 mg/m²IVDays 1 and 15
Dacarbazine375 mg/m²IVDays 1 and 15
Cycle length
Every 28 days
Duration
Depends on stage and PET; in advanced disease after a negative PET, cycles 3 to 6 as AVD

ABVD schedule; PET adaptation as in RATHL.

On the page “ABVD in Hodgkin lymphoma and AVD after a negative PET”

Doses follow the trial protocol, guideline or official drug label (source given in the notes of each regimen). Before prescribing, check blood counts, renal and hepatic function, drug interactions and the patient’s condition, and adjust the dose according to the drug label.

Treatment arms and regimens

1ABVD group (interim PET negative)

All patients first received 2 cycles of ABVD; after a negative interim PET-CT (score 1 to 3 on the 5-point scale, 9 to 13 days after day 15 of the second cycle), 4 further cycles of ABVD every 28 days: doxorubicin 25 mg/m², bleomycin 10,000 IU/m², vinblastine 6 mg/m² and dacarbazine 375 mg/m², all IV on days 1 and 15 (6 cycles in total).

Full dose and on schedule, without delay or dose reduction for haematological toxicity; dose capping was not allowed (except in severe obesity: ideal body weight, but not less than 85% of the dose calculated on actual weight); G-CSF was not routinely recommended. Bilirubin 1.7 to 2.5 times the upper limit of normal: 50% dose of doxorubicin and vinblastine; 2.5 to 4.0 times: 25% dose. Grade 3 or higher ileus: delay until recovery and continue vinblastine at 75% dose. Any patient with dyspnoea had a chest X-ray and pulmonary function tests before the next bleomycin dose; bleomycin was stopped only with clinical or radiographic evidence of pulmonary infiltrates or fibrosis or a fall in diffusing capacity to below 50% of predicted. Consolidation radiotherapy was not recommended.

2AVD group (interim PET negative)

After 2 cycles of ABVD (at the same doses) and a negative interim PET-CT, 4 cycles of AVD every 28 days: doxorubicin 25 mg/m², vinblastine 6 mg/m² and dacarbazine 375 mg/m², all IV on days 1 and 15 (bleomycin omitted). The same rules for full dosing, hepatic adjustment and vinblastine adjustment for ileus. Radiotherapy was not recommended in patients with a negative interim PET.

3Interim PET-positive group (non-randomised)

Escalation to BEACOPP according to each centre's prespecified choice (of 182 patients with a positive interim PET, 94 received BEACOPP-14 and 78 escalated BEACOPP); first cycle within 6 weeks of the last ABVD dose.

BEACOPP-14 (every 14 days): doxorubicin 25 mg/m² IV on day 1; cyclophosphamide 650 mg/m² IV on day 1; etoposide 100 mg/m² IV on days 1 to 3; procarbazine 100 mg/m² orally on days 1 to 7; prednisolone 80 mg/m² orally on days 1 to 7; bleomycin 10,000 units/m² IV on day 8; vincristine 1.4 mg/m² IV on day 8 (maximum 2 mg); G-CSF 263 or 300 micrograms (or equivalent) subcutaneously on days 9 to 13, or a single dose of pegfilgrastim.

Escalated BEACOPP (every 21 days): doxorubicin 35 mg/m² IV on day 1; cyclophosphamide 1250 mg/m² IV on day 1; etoposide 200 mg/m² IV on days 1 to 3; procarbazine 100 mg/m² orally on days 1 to 7; prednisolone 40 mg/m² orally on days 1 to 14; bleomycin 10,000 units/m² IV on day 8; vincristine 1.4 mg/m² IV on day 8 (maximum 2 mg); G-CSF 263 or 300 micrograms (or equivalent) subcutaneously from day 9 until count recovery, or a single dose of pegfilgrastim.

A third PET-CT after 4 cycles of BEACOPP-14 or 3 cycles of escalated BEACOPP; if negative, 2 further cycles of BEACOPP-14 or 1 further cycle of escalated BEACOPP; if positive, salvage therapy per local protocol. The next cycle started provided white cells were above 2.5×109/L and platelets above 80×109/L, and the day 8 drugs were given at full dose regardless of counts. In escalated BEACOPP, after any predefined toxicity (grade 4 leucopenia for more than 4 days, grade 4 thrombocytopenia, infection, mucositis or an adverse event requiring a 2-week delay), the cyclophosphamide and etoposide doses were reduced by one level on a 5-level scale (cyclophosphamide 1250, 1100, 950, 800, 650 and etoposide 200, 175, 150, 125, 100 mg/m²); with toxicity in 2 consecutive cycles, standard dosing for all subsequent cycles. Radiotherapy to sites with FDG uptake at the end of chemotherapy was allowed.

Source of the regimen details: RATHL trial protocol version 5.1 (20 September 2013; UCL Cancer Trials Centre) and full text of the paper (PMC4961236)

Doses are given for the information of specialists, as in this study’s protocol, and are not a prescription. Every drug must be prescribed by the treating physician for the individual patient.

Study population

Patients aged 18 or older with previously untreated, histologically confirmed advanced classical Hodgkin lymphoma who were able to receive a full course of combination chemotherapy. Advanced disease: Ann Arbor stage IIB to IV, or stage IIA with an adverse feature (bulky mass larger than 33% of the thoracic diameter or larger than 10 cm elsewhere, or at least three involved sites). All patients had a baseline PET-CT before treatment.

Endpoints

Primary endpoint: difference in 3-year progression-free survival between the two randomised groups, as a non-inferiority comparison to exclude a difference of 5 percentage points or more. The abstract also reports overall survival and respiratory adverse events.

Safety and side effects

Grade 3 or 4 adverse events in cycles 3 to 6 (ABVD versus AVD): any grade 3–4 event: 69% versus 65%; neutropenia 59% versus 59%; febrile neutropenia 5% versus 2%; any infection 15% versus 10%; pulmonary or respiratory events 3% versus 1% (dyspnoea 2% versus less than 0.5%; pneumonitis 1% versus less than 0.5%); thrombosis or embolism 4% versus 2%. The decline in diffusing capacity of the lung for carbon monoxide (DLco) from baseline to the end of treatment was 7.4 percentage points greater with ABVD (P<0.001), and the difference persisted at 1 year (4.6 percentage points; P=0.003). With BEACOPP-14 and escalated BEACOPP, grade 3–4 adverse events occurred in 80% and 83%, febrile neutropenia in 11% and 26%, and grade 3–4 thrombocytopenia in 19% and 42% (full text of the paper, Table 3).

Clinical significance and place in guidelines

This study shows that interim PET-CT after two cycles of ABVD can be used to adapt treatment of advanced Hodgkin lymphoma; in patients with a negative result, omitting bleomycin reduced pulmonary toxicity without a significant loss of efficacy, although the results fell slightly short of the specified non-inferiority margin. The place of this strategy in current guidelines should be checked in the latest guideline versions.

Limitations

The results fell slightly short of the specified non-inferiority margin (5 percentage points) (confidence interval from a lower limit of −3.2 to an upper limit of 5.3). Median follow-up is 41 months. The PET-positive group was not randomised. Other limitations are not stated in the abstract and should be checked in the full text of the paper.

This summary was prepared by the editorial team from the published paper; the original paper is the final reference. Read the original abstract on PubMed.